If You Can’t Attribute It, You’re Guessing

Dark blue background with a network of particles converging into a single flowing line of light, overlaid with the title 'If You Can't Attribute It, You're Guessing' and the Reach Digital logo

In the Content Marketing Institute’s 2025 B2B research, 56% of respondents cited difficulty attributing ROI to content, and the same share reported difficulty tracking customer journeys. That doesn’t mean they measure nothing. It means connecting activity to commercial results remains a challenge, even for dedicated marketing teams.

Traffic can go up. So can impressions, engagement and reach. Those numbers tell you something useful about attention, but they don’t tell you whether the spend is paying off. Better search visibility is encouraging. More people engaging with your social content is encouraging. Neither, on its own, tells you how many relevant enquiries became paying customers.

If you can’t connect leads and sales to the activity that helped bring them in, decisions about what to fund, cut or scale become much harder to defend.

That’s the argument for tracking: giving the business a clearer basis for decisions. You won’t capture every conversation, referral or touchpoint, and assigning credit to a channel doesn’t prove it caused a sale. But a useful, honest view of the journey is far better than a report that stops at attention.

An enquiry count only tells part of the story

Ask a founder how marketing’s going and you may get a monthly enquiry count. Ask where those enquiries came from, or how many became customers, and the answer can be much less clear. Often, nothing was set up to connect those stages.

An enquiry count is a useful starting point. Without source, lead quality and sales outcomes, though, it tells you little about where to invest next.

Consent choices add another limitation. As Google’s consent-mode documentation explains, basic consent mode blocks Google tags until consent is granted. Advanced consent mode can send cookieless signals when consent is denied, supporting modelling where eligible. That can help estimate gaps; it doesn’t recover a complete, identifiable journey for every visitor.

The size of those gaps depends on your audience and implementation. Treat them as a limitation to understand and report, while making sure you connect the enquiries and outcomes you can legitimately record.

More data isn’t the fix

Once someone notices the gap, the instinct is to ask for more data. More charts, more events, more detail. But a fuller report isn’t necessarily a more useful one.

A monthly report can take hours to produce and minutes to skim, then leave everyone with the same unanswered question: what was the activity worth? If nobody knows which decision a metric supports, adding it to the dashboard creates more work without much benefit.

The better questions are: “What are we tracking, why are we tracking it, and what would we do differently because of the result?” A button click, download or phone-call event should help answer a specific question. And clicking a phone number isn’t the same as having a useful sales conversation.

The questions that actually matter

Strip it back and there are two halves to the journey. First, what happened before someone got in touch?

  • Where did the lead come from, and what evidence supports that source?
  • Which pages or content helped them understand the offer?
  • Were they already familiar with the business, or discovering it for the first time?
  • Which pages help visitors take a useful next step, and which need improving?

Then there’s what happened after the enquiry:

  • Was the lead relevant, and how quickly did someone respond?
  • Was there a follow-up, or did the conversation go quiet?
  • Did they become a paying customer? If not, do you know why?
  • What revenue did they bring in, and did they buy again?

Website analytics can help with the first half. The second needs sales records and a consistent follow-up process. Connect the two and you can start distinguishing a marketing problem from a lead-quality or sales-process problem.

This matters more the longer your sales cycle is

Poor tracking makes an ineffective budget allocation harder to spot. The longer the gap between an enquiry and a sale, the longer that mistake can continue.

With a short sales cycle, you get feedback relatively quickly. With a sales cycle measured in months, campaigns, offers and sales activity may all change before a deal closes. Looking only at this month’s spend and this month’s revenue can give you a misleading picture.

Keep the original enquiry date and source attached to the lead, then record its progress and eventual outcome. Review groups of leads from the same period, allowing enough time for them to convert. That gives you a better basis for judging a campaign than comparing recent costs with sales that began somewhere else, months earlier.

A basic example of a five stage lead journey, from source through content, contact, follow-up and outcome.

What “enough” tracking actually looks like

You don’t need a complex CRM to get started. You need a reliable way to connect an enquiry with its source, follow-up and outcome, using the journey information available to you.

For each lead, start with a small, consistent set of fields:

  • Enquiry date and a unique lead reference.
  • Known source or campaign, plus the landing page where available.
  • The customer’s answer to “How did you hear about us?”, kept alongside tracked source data.
  • Lead quality, owner, first response and next follow-up.
  • Outcome, sale date and revenue, or the reason the lead was lost.

Leave genuinely unknown sources marked as unknown. A neat-looking report built on assumptions is less useful than an incomplete one you can trust.

An established CRM such as Salesforce or HubSpot can hold this information. We built Nexus, our lightweight alternative, for clients who needed to see leads from source through to outcome without the complexity of a larger sales platform. A consistently maintained spreadsheet can also be a sensible starting point, with a dashboard added when it helps people use the data.

The tool matters less than the process. Give someone responsibility for keeping records current, agree how often to review them, and budget for that time. Compare marketing costs with qualified leads, customers and revenue, then consider margins and delivery costs before calling the result profitable.

Over time, repeat purchases and customer lifetime value add depth. You don’t need that full picture on day one. Start by knowing where leads come from and what happens after they arrive.

That’s why tracking is the second stage of the Startup Marketing Investment Framework: clarity first, then tracking, before increasing investment in conversion or acquisition. The aim is to give the next budget decision a firmer foundation.

Start with your recent enquiries. Can you connect each one to a source, an owner and an outcome? Wherever that chain breaks is a useful place to begin.

Oliver Westrup


About the author

Oliver Westrup
Retained Services Director at Reach Digital

Oliver Westrup is Retained Services Director at Reach Digital and the developer of the Startup Marketing Investment Framework. He works with founders and marketing teams to sequence budget, prioritise channels, and build marketing systems that hold up as a business grows.


Did you find this article useful? Share it with a friend or colleague